A damning audit on the EU in Kosovo

By Andrea Lorenzo Capussela  -  08.11.2012 / 04:15 CET
The EU's efforts to tackle corruption in Kosovo have had minimal impact

The European Court of Auditors has audited the European Union's efforts to improve the rule of law in Kosovo and on 30 October published a report that is an admirable, if charitably narrow, exercise in accountability. Little praise and stern criticism is offered to Eulex, the rule-of-law mission, whereas the European Commission is found to have been relatively efficient. But both committed strategic errors. 

Organised crime and corruption remain high in Kosovo, and its authorities seem reluctant to tackle them, the report finds. Scattered across the report, a dozen instances are also noted in which policies made corruption easier or its repression more difficult: for instance, the authorities declined Commission advice to restructure the public-procurement institutions and accepted less than half of the recommendations formulated by EU-funded anti-corruption experts, without explanation. This reveals a lucid, strategic approach: Kosovo is in fact governed by a largely predatory elite that uses corruption not just for enrichment but also to support the patronage system upon which its power rests, and to favour the organised crime it often benefits from.

This picture was known when Eulex was granted its mandate to strengthen Kosovo's rule-of-law institutions and repress serious crime: the idea was that while guiding the predictably slow progress of those institutions, the mission's investigators, prosecutors and judges would start cleaning up the country. According to the report, Kosovo's police and judiciary have made no progress since Eulex started assisting them: they remain subject to political interference and utterly unable to confront serious crime. The mission is found to have worked well in customs, but all it did was not ruin a service that already worked rather well (revenue merely tracked the growth of imports): Eulex should have concentrated its resources on the real problems.

Eulex's graver failures were in the other part of its mission's mandate, regrettably not covered by the report. Its near-complete inaction on high-level corruption and organised crime has consolidated a ten-year tradition of impunity. And some inexplicable mistakes have objectively strengthened the leading faction of Kosovo's elite, which could thus spread its influence so pervasively across the institutions that Kosovo is now at risk of state capture, as the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) recently noted.

It is against this background that we should read the report's anodyne observation that EU strategies in Kosovo have neglected the internal security of the Union. For the organised crime that operates in Kosovo – which deals in narcotics, weapons, money-laundering, human trafficking and illegal migration, and flourishes thanks to endemic corruption and near-complete impunity – still poses a serious threat to member states. More so, probably, than when Eulex was deployed almost five years ago.

The EU's common foreign policy has structural flaws: Kosovo crudely demonstrated them when its independence split the member states, five of which still refuse to recognise it. Yet the EU restored some semblance of unity by establishing Eulex, which is its largest mission ever and was heralded as the ‘flagship' of its security and defence policy. Because Kosovo always mattered to the EU – since the 1999 conflict it has received almost €4 billion (including the cost of Eulex), by far the largest per-capita flow of EU aid ever.

Such political and financial investment implies that the effectiveness – if not the strategic adequacy and coherence – of the common foreign policy must be measured above all in Kosovo. This debacle has, therefore, seriously damaged its credibility. If accountability will not be enforced across Eulex's chain of command there can be little hope of improving implementation of the foreign policy of the EU.

Andrea Lorenzo Capussela was head of the economics unit of the International Civilian Office in Kosovo in 2009-11.

© 2014 European Voice. All rights reserved.

Subscribe to European Voice from €3 per week

Varrow

Most viewed in Foreign affairs

EU steps up criticism as Turkey bans YouTube

‘Where does this end?' asks European commissioner for enlargement.

Turkey_flag(R)

Instability dominates in EU's neighbourhood

Tunisia, Moldova and Georgia emerge strongly from an review of 2013, a year shaped by crises.

Ukraine protest

Ukraine separatists snub Geneva deal

Pro-Russian groups refuse to leave occupied buildings.

Separatist

Related articles

Macedonians are expected to re-elect President Gjorge Ivanov.

Pro-Russian groups refuse to leave occupied buildings.

The managing director of the World Economic Forum says that the popular upheaval in Ukraine has primarily been a striving for better governance, more effective institutions and a state that serves its people.

Parliament agrees to three legal amendments.

The European Union on Monday eased its call for constitutional change in Bosnia and Herzegovina, a switch from the demand that has dominated its policy towards the country over the past year.

Advertisement

Comments

 

Your comment
Please note: The fields followed by an asterisk (*) are obligatory fields

Comment*

Name*
E-mail*
Website

Please, copy the code on the left into the box on the right

 I accept the Terms & conditions
 I would like to share my e-mail & website

Advertisement