Monday 21 April 2014
Advertise  |  Subscribe  |  Register  | 

Close

About cookies: we use cookies to support features like login and sharing articles. Keep cookies enabled to enjoy the full site experience. By browsing our site with cookies enabled, you are agreeing to their use. Review our cookies information for more details.

Flawed search for the truth

27.09.2012 / 03:50 CET
David Lesch claims to have had exceptional insight into the workings of the Syrian regime and of Bashar Assad.

Of the three books on Syria and the Arab uprisings reviewed here, David Lesch's makes, perhaps, the biggest claim – and delivers the biggest disappointment.

Lesch's claim is to have had exceptional insight into the workings of the Syrian regime and of Bashar Assad, who took over as Syria's leader in 2000 after the death of his father, Hafez. Lesch, a professor of Middle Eastern history at Trinity University in San Antonio, Texas, has travelled to Syria more than 20 times since 1989, met Assad regularly in 2004-08 and also interviewed his wife Asma and senior figures in the leadership. “This unique access meant that I got to know Assad probably better than anyone in the West,” he writes.

Yet throughout the book, Lesch prevaricates on some of the most important questions about Assad and his role in the vicious crackdown on the uprising that began in March last year. For example, he writes that Assad, who “seems to view the security organs as a necessary evil”, was “either unwilling or powerless to stop what in Syria is a reflexive response to perceived threat” when the uprising broke out. But reluctance is not the same as inability; morally and politically, the distinction is absolutely crucial if we are to understand what has been happening in Syria.

Such ambiguities – and they are numerous – might be explained by Lesch's earlier, largely positive view of Assad, set out in “The new lion of Damascus”, published in 2005. The events of the past 18 months have proved that view wrong, and “The fall of the house of Assad” is a corrective.

Indeed, Assad was “not up to the task”, Lesch concludes. “He was shortsighted and became deluded. He failed miserably.” But in his discussion of recent events, one senses the author's unwillingness to be as clear. For example, he writes about regime propaganda and activists' propaganda that “the truth probably lay somewhere in the middle, although most of the journalists I spoke to...were virtually unanimous in maintaining that...the truth was closer to the way the opposition presented matters”. Why does Lesch in effect reject these journalists' assessment? Does he have any evidence to claim that the truth is to be found “in the middle”? He does not tell us. As so often in this flawed book, Lesch simply leaves us guessing.

Toby Vogel

Syria: the fall of the house of Assad

By David Lesch (276 pages)

Yale University Press, €23

© 2014 European Voice. All rights reserved.
Varrow

Most viewed in Foreign affairs

EU steps up criticism as Turkey bans YouTube

‘Where does this end?' asks European commissioner for enlargement.

Turkey_flag(R)

Instability dominates in EU's neighbourhood

Tunisia, Moldova and Georgia emerge strongly from an review of 2013, a year shaped by crises.

Ukraine protest

Deny Moscow a new front in Bosnia You need an active subscription to read this article

The West needs a strategy to prevent Russia stoking the separatist aspirations of the leader of Bosnia's ethnic Serbs.

opedbosnia2703
Book_Syria1

Related articles

Pro-Russian groups refuse to leave occupied buildings.

The managing director of the World Economic Forum says that the popular upheaval in Ukraine has primarily been a striving for better governance, more effective institutions and a state that serves its people.

Parliament agrees to three legal amendments.

The European Union on Monday eased its call for constitutional change in Bosnia and Herzegovina, a switch from the demand that has dominated its policy towards the country over the past year.

EEAS to reinforce its delegations in Ukraine.

Advertisement

Comments

 

Your comment
Please note: The fields followed by an asterisk (*) are obligatory fields

Comment*

Name*
E-mail*
Website

Please, copy the code on the left into the box on the right

 I accept the Terms & conditions
 I would like to share my e-mail & website

Advertisement

Cookies info | Privacy policy | Terms & conditions